How to Start Your Own Skincare Brand With No Experience

What ingredients and claims are allowed in skincare, and how do I avoid regulatory trouble?

By Blake Mereby · Last reviewed November 1, 2026

Skincare regulatory compliance hinges on one critical distinction: whether your product makes a cosmetic claim or a drug claim. Cosmetic claims—"moisturizes," "nourishes," "softens," "cleanses"—require only basic ingredient compliance and safety testing. Drug claims—"reduces wrinkles," "treats acne," "heals eczema," "promotes collagen production"—turn your product into a drug under FDA law (in the US) or equivalent regulations elsewhere, requiring FDA pre-approval, clinical trials, and a New Drug Application (NDA), which costs $10 million to $100 million and takes 5 to 10 years. The difference between "silky, smooth skin" (cosmetic) and "reduces the appearance of fine lines by 25%" (drug claim if not substantiated) is your entire go-to-market strategy. Most first-time skincare founders inadvertently make drug claims in their marketing without realizing the regulatory landmine they have stepped on.

In the United States, the FDA defines cosmetics as products intended to cleanse, beautify, promote attractiveness, or alter appearance without affecting the body's structure or function. The moment your marketing implies the product will change the body's function—cure acne bacteria, stimulate collagen, reduce inflammation—the FDA reclassifies it as a drug. In practice, this means you can say "smooths the appearance of fine lines" (cosmetic claim, describing visual outcome), but you cannot say "reduces fine lines by increasing dermal collagen" (drug claim, implying internal function). You can say "helps reduce excess oil" (cosmetic), but not "treats acne" or "eliminates acne-causing bacteria" (drug). The FDA has published a guide to cosmetic vs. drug claims; before you finalize your marketing copy, run it past a regulatory compliance specialist or your manufacturer's compliance team.

Ingredient restrictions differ sharply by region. In the US, the FDA maintains a list of banned and restricted cosmetic ingredients (about 11 fully banned substances, like formaldehyde and chloroform, and hundreds of restricted ingredients). Most common skincare actives—niacinamide, vitamin C, peptides, hyaluronic acid, salicylic acid (at 0.5–2%), glycolic acid (at 4–15%)—are allowed as cosmetics if used at permitted concentrations. However, the EU bans or restricts hundreds more: titanium dioxide (banned in some forms), certain UV filters, some preservatives, and most botanical extracts above trace levels. Australia (TGA) and Canada (Health Canada) have their own lists. If you are selling internationally, you must reformulate for each region, which adds cost and complexity.

Active ingredients commonly used in skincare and their regulatory status vary: Vitamin C (L-ascorbic acid) is allowed in all major markets as a cosmetic; however, certain stabilized forms or delivery systems may require stability testing. Retinol and retinyl palmitate are allowed in cosmetics in most regions (the US, EU, Canada); retinoids (adapalene, tretinoin) are drugs and require prescription. Alpha hydroxy acids (AHA, e.g., glycolic acid, lactic acid) are allowed as cosmetics under 10% concentration in most regions and under 8% in Australia. Salicylic acid (BHA) is allowed as a cosmetic at 0.5–2% in the US and EU but not in some other markets. Niacinamide is allowed in all major markets. Peptides are allowed as cosmetics; claims about collagen stimulation must be cosmetic, not drug claims. Hyaluronic acid is allowed everywhere. Botanical extracts (green tea, resveratrol, vitamin E) are allowed but some regions have banned specific botanicals (e.g., the EU restricts concentrations of certain plant-derived preservatives).

Preservative systems are the most heavily regulated layer. Your formula must include a broad-spectrum preservative to prevent mold, bacteria, and fungi. The allowed preservatives vary: Phenoxyethanol is allowed up to 1% in the US and EU but banned in Canada and restricted in some other countries. Parabens (methylparaben, propylparaben, etc.) are allowed in the US, EU, and most markets under 0.8% combined, though the EU restricts certain paraben combinations. Natural or organic brands often use rosemary extract or citric acid as preservatives, but these are weaker and require cold-chain storage or lower water content to be effective. Talk to your chemist about the preservative system that matches your target market and your "natural" positioning, if any.

Claims substantiation is the hidden cost. If you want to say "clinically proven to reduce fine lines," you must either conduct a clinical efficacy study (cost: $5,000 to $20,000, timeline: 8 to 12 weeks) or rely on published peer-reviewed studies of your active ingredients and compile a dossier proving the ingredient at your concentration is as effective as the published research claims. The FTC requires that before you make any efficacy claim, you have "competent and reliable scientific evidence" backing it. Many indie brands make claims without this backing and risk FDA warning letters or FTC enforcement action. A safer strategy for first-time founders: use cosmetic claims only ("moisturizes," "hydrates," "brightens the appearance") and rely on ingredient reputation and customer testimonials, not claims about internal function.

Regional compliance steps are mandatory before launch. In the US: file a Cosmetic Facility and Product List (CFPL) with the FDA once your formula is final; this is free and takes 1–2 weeks. In the EU: submit your formula to the CPNP (Cosmetics Products Notification Portal) and wait for review (1–4 weeks). In Australia: register with the TGA. In Canada: ensure your ingredients are on the Cosmetic Ingredient Hotlist and file with Health Canada. Your chemist or manufacturer should handle this, but verify it in writing before production. Many founders skip this step, launch their product, and face legal trouble six months later when a distributor asks for compliance documentation they do not have.

A critical mistake first-timers make is assuming "natural" or "organic" ingredients are automatically safe and require no testing. Organic certification (COSMOS, ECOCERT, etc.) verifies farming and sourcing standards, not safety or efficacy. A 100% organic serum with no synthetic preservative is still required to pass microbiological challenge testing and stability testing to prove it will not spoil in the customer's bathroom. Many natural brands have recalled products due to mold or bacterial contamination because they underestimated the stability layer.

Before finalizing your formula and marketing, consult your chemist and a regulatory expert. AJ Cosmo Labs can connect you with approved chemists who are experienced in multi-market compliance. Have them review your ingredient list, your proposed marketing claims, and your target markets (US, EU, Asia, etc.) and flag any issues before you spend money on manufacturing. The cost of a compliance review (usually $500 to $1,500) is a rounding error compared to the cost of a product recall, FDA warning letter, or lawsuit from customers.

Ingredients in this answer: Titanium Dioxide · Hyaluronic Acid · Niacinamide · Salicylic Acid · Glycolic Acid

Read the full guide on How to Start Your Own Skincare Brand With No Experience →

More about How to Start Your Own Skincare Brand With No Experience

Tell us about your product

Tell us what you're selling and where. You can hire a vetted cosmetic chemist on AJ Cosmo Labs to review your formula and labeling. Starting is free.

Free to start · no credit card · continue in your browser or the iPhone app.

Have a product idea?

Connect with vetted cosmetic chemists and custom labs on AJ Cosmo Labs.

Get on the App Store Open the web app