The short answer is: it depends on what claims you make and what concentration of salicylic acid you use.
The FDA does not pre-approve cosmetics before they go to market, but salicylic acid above 0.5% used with an acne-related claim (e.g., "clears breakouts," "unclogs pores," "treats acne") converts the product into an OTC drug under the acne monograph (21 CFR Part 333, Subpart D). OTC drugs require no pre-market FDA approval but do require compliance with the monograph's permitted active ingredients, concentrations, and labeling — specifically, a Drug Facts panel formatted per 21 CFR 201.66. The manufacturer must hold an FDA Drug Establishment Registration and manufacture under 21 CFR Part 211 cGMP for pharmaceutical products, which is a meaningfully higher standard than cosmetic GMP.
Under MoCRA (Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act, signed December 2022), cosmetic manufacturers and brand owners must now register their facilities and list products with FDA — even for purely cosmetic products. This registration opened in 2023 and applies to all companies marketing cosmetics in the US market. Your contract manufacturer handles facility registration; you as the brand owner handle product listing if you are the responsible person.
If you keep salicylic acid at or below 0.5% and make no acne treatment claims, the product is a cosmetic and the OTC drug pathway does not apply. You still need accurate INCI labeling, safe formulation (supported by your manufacturer's safety data), and MoCRA product registration, but the compliance burden is substantially lower.
For EU distribution, there is no pre-market approval either, but you need a cosmetic product safety report prepared by a qualified safety assessor (a toxicologist with relevant credentials) and a completed Product Information File (PIF) before placing the product on the market.
Niacinamide has no drug classification in any major regulatory system and does not affect the regulatory status of the toner.
Ingredients in this answer: Salicylic Acid · Niacinamide
Read the full guide on Private Label Salicylic Acid Niacinamide Toner Manufacturer →