Yes, both options are available with most cosmetic co-manufacturers, and the choice carries real commercial and regulatory implications worth understanding before you brief your manufacturer.
Fragrance-free is increasingly the default positioning for AHA toners because the core consumer buying a mandelic acid toner is often sensitive-skin or acne-prone, and fragrance (including essential oils) is the leading cause of cosmetic sensitization. A fragrance-free claim on your label — distinct from "unscented," which means masking fragrance may still be present — resonates strongly with this demographic and is easy to substantiate. From a formulation standpoint, removing fragrance at low pH also reduces the risk of ingredient interactions; some fragrance components are unstable or reactive at pH 3.0–4.0.
If you do want a fragrance, several considerations apply. First, IFRA (International Fragrance Association) standards restrict certain aromatic compounds in leave-on face products — your fragrance must comply with current IFRA standards (Edition 51 or later), and this compliance documentation should come from your fragrance supplier. Second, at low pH, certain floral and citrus top notes can degrade or shift, meaning the fragrance you smell in the bottle may differ from what the consumer smells 6 months later. Your stability testing should include a sensory panel evaluation of fragrance integrity at the 12-week accelerated stability mark. Third, the EU Cosmetics Regulation requires the declaration of 26 listed allergenic fragrance ingredients on-label if present above 0.001% (leave-on) or 0.01% (rinse-off). If you add a complex fragrance blend, your formulator must obtain a full disclosure from the fragrance house to check for listed allergens.
A popular middle path is adding a single plant-derived, skin-functional ingredient that contributes a subtle sensory note without being classified as a fragrance — for example, a low percentage of bisabolol (from chamomile, with a faint floral character) or panthenol, which has no perceivable scent but signals skin-care intent. This lets you offer a pleasant sensory experience without triggering fragrance labeling requirements.
Discuss your scent strategy with your cosmetic chemist early, because changing from fragrance-free to fragranced (or vice versa) after stability testing begins resets the testing clock. AJ Cosmo Labs lets you include scent preferences and allergen-free requirements directly in your project brief so manufacturers can flag capability and ingredient sourcing upfront before any work begins.
Ingredients in this answer: Mandelic Acid · Bisabolol · Panthenol
Read the full guide on Private Label Mandelic Acid Toner Manufacturer Low MOQ →