How to Find a Makeup Chemist for Foundation Shades

What are the main regulatory challenges when formulating foundation for different skin tones and regions?

By Blake Mereby · Last reviewed October 13, 2026

Foundation formulations face distinct regulatory constraints depending on the region where you sell, and these constraints directly affect your shade range, pigment choices, and labelling claims. A chemist who understands regional regulatory landscapes can help you avoid costly reformulations or delays when you want to expand internationally.

In the United States (FDA jurisdiction), foundation is classified as a colour cosmetic and is subject to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act and the Colour Additives Amendment. Approved cosmetic colorants (iron oxides CI 77489, CI 77491, CI 77492, CI 77499; mica; titanium dioxide; and FDA-approved D&C and FD&C lakes) can be used without pre-market approval, but any colourant not on the FDA's permitted list is prohibited. This is generally not restrictive for foundation: iron oxides cover most natural undertones, and approved lakes extend the range to reds and oranges if you want to offer warm or warm-neutral deep shades. The main US regulatory challenge is not pigment availability but claim substantiation: if you claim your foundation is "long-wearing," "waterproof," "sweat-resistant," or "transfer-resistant," you must have testing data (usually wear-time tests or ASTM methods) to support it. Any health or benefit claim (e.g., "reduces the appearance of fine lines") triggers stricter review. Fragrance ingredients must be listed generically as "fragrance" if intentionally added, and allergens (e.g., limonene, eugenol) must be disclosed if they exceed certain thresholds.

In the European Union (CPNP framework), foundation is also a colour cosmetic but is governed by stricter rules. The EU maintains a Positive List of approved colourants (Annex IV of the Cosmetics Regulation 1223/2009), and iron oxides and mica are approved, but some D&C lakes permitted in the US are banned in the EU. For example, D&C Red No. 7 and D&C Red No. 9 are approved in the US but prohibited in the EU; this means a deep red-undertone shade you formulated for the US may require a reformulation (substituting permitted EU lakes or adjusting iron oxide ratios) for the EU market. The EU also requires a formal safety assessment (Cosmetic Safety Assessment per Annex I) before you can notify the product in the CPNP; this assessment must evaluate the toxicity, concentration, and consumer exposure of every ingredient, and typically costs €1,500–€3,000. Once notified, your product appears in the CPNP database and is recognized as compliant across all EU member states, the UK (post-Brexit, via the UKCA scheme), and countries that recognize EU cosmetics standards.

Multi-tone compatibility: A critical issue for foundation brands launching across regions is ensuring shade names, undertone descriptions, and regulatory claims are consistent. If you market a shade as "Warm Undertone" in the US but that shade contains an EU-banned pigment, you cannot sell it in the EU without reformulation. Some brands solve this by creating a "US Formula" and an "EU Formula" for the same shade, with slightly different pigment ratios but visually identical appearance; others redesign their palette to use only EU-approved pigments so they can sell a single formula worldwide. A chemist experienced in multi-region launches will flag these issues early and recommend a unified pigment strategy from the start.

Canada and Australia impose similar constraints: Health Canada approves a closed list of cosmetic colourants (permitting iron oxides and some lakes but banning others), and the Australian Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) maintains its own Cosmetic Ingredients List. If you plan a three-region launch (US, EU, Canada), your chemist should recommend pigment selections that are approved in all three, even if it narrows your shade options slightly — this is far cheaper than reformulating once you discover a pigment is banned mid-launch.

Claim regulation is stringent across all regions. In the EU, claims like "long-wear" must be substantiated with wear-time testing (typically ASTM D2025 or similar), and claims that imply therapeutic benefit ("reduces shine for up to 8 hours") must be carefully worded to avoid triggering drug classification. In the US, similar substantiation is required, and claims about health (e.g., "reduces acne" or "treats oily skin") automatically classify the product as a drug, triggering FDA pre-market approval, which is expensive and usually avoided by cosmetics brands.

Shade-range and undertone labelling: Regulatory bodies do not mandate specific undertone names (e.g., "Warm," "Cool," "Neutral"), but your undertone descriptions must be accurate and not misleading. If a shade appears very yellow to the naked eye, you cannot label it as "neutral" or "cool." Some brands use numeric systems (100, 110, 120) paired with undertone descriptors (Warm 100, Neutral 110). The EU requires ingredient declarations in INCI (International Nomenclature of Cosmetic Ingredients) format and forbids false or unsubstantiated geographic claims (e.g., you cannot claim a shade is "inspired by African skin tones" if you have not consulted or credited African communities). The US has less prescriptive labelling rules but requires that the ingredient list and net quantity be clearly visible and legible.

Preservation and shelf-life: If your foundation contains water or other hydrophilic ingredients, you must include a preservative system (e.g., phenoxyethanol, methylisothiazolinone, or a blend). The EU has banned or restricted several preservatives (formaldehyde, methylchloroisothiazolinone, certain parabens above certain levels in leave-on products), whereas the US permits a wider range. Your chemist must select a preservative approved in all target regions and validate its efficacy (demonstrating that it prevents microbial growth and meets USP or Ph. Eur. standards for microbial limits: typically <1,000 CFU/g bacteria, <100 CFU/g fungi, and no Staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, or other pathogens). Stability testing — placing samples at 25 °C / 60% RH, 40 °C / 75% RH, and (optionally) 4 °C for 3–12 months — is required to support a shelf-life claim (e.g., "12 months after opening"). EU regulations require an Expiry Date (EXP) on the label; the US does not mandate an expiry date but recommends it for consumer safety.

Safety assessment depth: The EU and Canada require more rigorous upfront safety documentation than the US. In the US, cosmetic companies are responsible for safety, but there is no pre-market notification requirement (except for colour additives, which have their own approval pathway); you can launch a product and later notify the FDA if you choose, or not at all. In the EU, a safety assessment and CPNP notification are mandatory before sale. In Canada, cosmetics are also notified post-market but regulations are stricter than the US. If you plan international expansion, your chemist should begin with EU-level documentation (full safety assessment, stability data, microbiological testing) because this typically satisfies or exceeds requirements elsewhere.

A common mistake: assuming a foundation formula approved and selling in the US will work immediately in the EU. In reality, pigment substitutions, preservative changes, and safety assessments can take 4–12 weeks and cost $2,000–$5,000. Building this into your launch timeline and budget from the start — ideally by working with a chemist who has multi-region experience — prevents delays. On AJ Cosmo Labs, you can filter for chemists with EU Cosmetics Regulation experience or ask directly about their familiarity with multi-region launches before you hire.

Ingredients in this answer: Titanium Dioxide · Iron Oxides · Methylchloroisothiazolinone · Phenoxyethanol

Read the full guide on How to Find a Makeup Chemist for Foundation Shades →

More about How to Find a Makeup Chemist for Foundation Shades

Tell us about your product

Tell us what you're selling and where. You can hire a vetted cosmetic chemist on AJ Cosmo Labs to review your formula and labeling. Starting is free.

Free to start · no credit card · continue in your browser or the iPhone app.

Have a product idea?

Connect with vetted cosmetic chemists and custom labs on AJ Cosmo Labs.

Get on the App Store Open the web app