Matching foundation shades to diverse skin tones requires a systematic approach: you need reference samples from across the skin-tone spectrum, a colour-matching protocol that accounts for both lightness (luminosity) and undertone (hue), and honest feedback from testers with a range of skin depths and undertones. A chemist cannot formulate equitable shades in isolation; they depend on your input to ensure every skin tone feels represented and the palette does not default to light-skin-centric undertones.
Start with a shade-range strategy. Define the breadth of your palette: are you launching 10, 15, 20, or 40 shades? A limited range (8–10 shades) typically covers fair to medium-deep skin tones but may leave some medium-deep and very deep skin tones with one-size-fits-all options or no match. A broader range (20–40 shades) allows you to offer multiple undertone options at every depth, so that a consumer with a medium-deep skin tone can choose between warm, neutral, and cool undertones. Industry leaders like Fenty Beauty (launched with 40 shades) and Black Opal (10–15 shades for deep skin tones) pioneered different strategies; Fenty's breadth has become a benchmark for inclusivity, though smaller brands often start with 12–15 and expand based on sales data and customer feedback.
Define undertone categories. Most shade systems use three main undertones: warm (yellow, golden, peachy undertones), neutral (a balance of warm and cool, appearing neither yellow nor pink), and cool (pink, red, or blue undertones). Some brands add a fourth category, "deep warm" or "deep neutral," specifically for very deep skin tones where undertones can appear shifted compared to lighter depths. This is critical because the same iron oxide blend may read as warm-yellow on fair skin and appear more neutral or even slightly ashy on deep skin due to contrast and optical illusion. Communicate these categories to your chemist upfront so they understand the undertone ranges they need to cover.
Build a reference sample set. Before your chemist begins formulation, assemble a palette of reference shades — either from existing commercial foundations (e.g., Fenty, MAC Face & Body, Black Opal, Revlon, L'Oréal True Match) or colour swatches from beauty bloggers, shade-matching apps, or your own mood board. Organize references by undertone and depth, creating a matrix. For example: Fair Warm, Fair Neutral, Fair Cool, Light Warm, Light Neutral, Light Cool, Medium Warm, Medium Neutral, Medium Cool, Medium-Deep Warm, Medium-Deep Neutral, Medium-Deep Cool, Deep Warm, Deep Neutral, Deep Cool, Very Deep Warm, Very Deep Neutral, Very Deep Cool. This matrix shows your chemist that you expect three undertone options at most skin depths, preventing a formula that only covers warm tones or skips deep cool undertones entirely.
Use spectroscopic data and colour theory. Modern colour-matching uses spectrophotometers (instruments that measure the light reflectance of a colour across wavelengths) and software that translates reflectance into colour spaces like CIELAB (L*, a*, b*). L* represents lightness (0 = black, 100 = white); a* represents red-green (positive = red, negative = green); b* represents yellow-blue (positive = yellow, negative = blue). When your chemist prepares shade samples, ask them to provide spectral data (L*, a*, b* values) for each sample so you can compare them to your reference set mathematically. A sample with L* 45, a* +5, b* +15 is medium-depth with warm undertones; one with L* 45, a* +2, b* -3 is medium-depth with cool undertones. If two shades have the same L* but very different a*/b* values, they are different undertones at the same depth — which is good for offering choice. If your palette has a gap (no shade with L* 52, a* 0, b* 0, for example), you might need an additional neutral shade. Colour-matching software helps you visualize these gaps and guide the chemist's formulation.
Build a diverse tester panel. Once your chemist delivers initial samples, do not rely on a single tester or a small group. Recruit a panel of 8–15 people spanning: skin depths (fair, light, light-medium, medium, medium-deep, deep, very deep), undertones (warm, neutral, cool), and skin types (dry, oily, combination, sensitive). Provide each tester with a standardized feedback form: "Shade [X] on me. Does it match? Does the undertone feel right — too warm, too cool, or neutral? Does it look ashy or oxidized? Would you buy this?" Emphasize that you need honest feedback, including "this shade missed me" or "you have no shade for warm deep tones." A frequent mistake is skipping feedback from very deep or very light testers because the designer feels those tones are "edge cases"; in reality, excluding any depth or undertone signals bias in your product development.
Avoid bias in naming and marketing. Shade names should be descriptive of the undertone or inspiration, not exclusionary. Avoid names like "Nude" (which defaults to light, cool skin tones) or "Tan" (which centers medium skin). Instead, use numbers (100, 110, 120), descriptive names by undertone (Warm Golden, Cool Rosy, Neutral Beige), or inclusive descriptors (Golden Amber, Rosy Almond, Warm Cocoa). If you use inclusivity-focused names ("For All Skins," "Unified Palette"), ensure your actual formula and shade range back that up; marketing language without product substance erodes brand trust. Fenty's approach — straightforward numbers and undertone clarity without aspirational naming — has become a best practice.
Iterate with real-world testing. Launch your shade range as a beta or limited run first if possible (a pilot batch of 200–500 units), sell or distribute to a diverse customer base, and gather sales data and qualitative feedback. Which shades sell out first? Which are returned? Which customers feel the palette missed them? This real-world data is invaluable for your next production run or shade expansion. Many brands find that their initial undertone assumptions were incomplete — perhaps they overestimated demand for cool undertones and underestimated warm deep tones, or vice versa. A second MOQ can correct these imbalances.
Work with your chemist on undertone adjustments. When your tester panel or beta customers feedback that a shade is too yellow or too ashy, the chemist adjusts the iron oxide ratios: increasing iron oxide red CI 77491 and decreasing iron oxide yellow CI 77492 shifts the undertone cooler and more pinky; increasing yellow and decreasing red shifts it warmer. This is not a one-ingredient fix; it requires reformulation and re-stability testing (2–3 weeks per revision). Budget for 2–3 undertone revision rounds in your initial project fee to account for this.
On AJ Cosmo Labs, you can post a hire request for a makeup chemist and clearly outline your shade range, undertone strategy, and commitment to diverse testing: "Seeking a cosmetic chemist with experience formulating inclusive foundation palettes across 20+ shades and multiple undertones. I will provide a tester panel of [X] people representing [specific skin depths and undertones]. Expected to collaborate on iterative undertone refinements." Chemists who have worked with diverse brands or have stated multi-tone formulation experience are well-positioned to guide you through this process and flag potential gaps early.
Read the full guide on How to Find a Makeup Chemist for Foundation Shades →