Buy a Ready-Made Skincare Formula Instead of Developing One

Can I modify or improve a ready-made formula after I buy it?

By Blake Mereby · Last reviewed November 1, 2026

Yes, you can modify a ready-made formula after you buy it, but you need permission from the supplier and you must understand the legal and technical implications. Modifying a formula is common—many brands buy a base formula and then tweak it to match their brand's positioning, improve stability, adjust the texture, or add or remove an ingredient. However, modifications are not free or risk-free; they require a chemist's involvement, additional testing, and a new compliance assessment.

First, check your supply agreement or license. Does it explicitly allow you to modify the formula? Some suppliers grant you the right to modify; others forbid it and reserve the right to modify for themselves. If your agreement is silent on modifications, contact the supplier and ask. If they do not allow modifications, you may still be able to negotiate, especially if you are a high-volume customer. Non-exclusive formulas are more likely to have restrictions on modification than exclusive formulas.

If modifications are allowed, understand the technical scope. Changing a single ingredient (e.g., swapping one preservative for another, increasing the concentration of an active, removing a fragrance) is a minor modification and can usually be done by a chemist in 1 to 2 weeks at a cost of £300 to £1,000. Changing the formula's core (e.g., converting an emulsion to a lightweight serum, adding multiple new actives, changing the pH) is a major modification and effectively becomes a custom re-formulation, which costs £2,000 to £8,000 and takes 6 to 12 weeks.

After a modification, you must re-test and re-certify the formula. At minimum, you should run a basic stability assessment: store samples at room temperature, 40 °C / 75% RH, and 2 to 8 °C for 4 to 8 weeks, then assess for separation, color change, odor, and potency (if applicable). This takes 4 to 8 weeks and costs £800 to £2,000 at a contract lab. In the EU, if you modify the formula, you must also obtain a new safety assessment and update your CPNP registration. In the US, you must confirm the new formula still meets FDA compliance (all new ingredients must be approved cosmetic ingredients or GRAS, and no banned substances). The cost and timeline for a new safety assessment is the same as the initial assessment: 2 to 4 weeks, £600 to £1,500.

A real example: You buy a non-exclusive moisturizer formula and want to add a trendy ingredient—bakuchiol (a plant-based retinol alternative)—to differentiate your product. The supplier may not have bakuchiol in their base formula. You hire a chemist to add bakuchiol at 2% concentration, adjust the other ingredients to maintain the formula's stability and texture, and test the modified formula. This takes 1 to 2 weeks and costs £500 to £1,200. Then you run stability testing at 40 °C / 75% RH for 8 weeks (because bakuchiol can degrade under heat and light) and get a revised safety assessment to confirm bakuchiol's safety and the adjusted ingredient list. Total cost: £1,500 to £3,200; total timeline: 10 to 12 weeks from modification brief to a compliant, tested, modified formula.

Another scenario: You buy an exclusive formula but want to add a proprietary ingredient or adjust the preservative system for a premium positioning. You negotiate with the original supplier or hire a new chemist to make the changes. If you hire a new chemist, the original supplier may object if the license forbids it. To avoid conflict, involve the original supplier in the modification decision, or negotiate a clause that allows you to hire a third-party chemist to improve the formula. This is becoming more common: many suppliers now understand that brands want to evolve their products, and they are willing to allow modifications as long as the formula remains fundamentally theirs and you do not sell the modified formula to competitors.

A critical legal point: If you modify a formula significantly, you may create new IP. If the original supplier claims ownership of the formula, they may also claim ownership of your modifications, depending on the language in your agreement. To avoid disputes, clarify in writing: If I modify the formula, do I own the modifications, or do you? Can I claim the product as my own improvement? This is especially important if you plan to file a patent or trademark the modified formula or make proprietary claims about it.

Common mistakes with modifications: (1) Modifying a formula without testing, then launching and discovering the product has separated or degraded after 3 months on shelves. (2) Adding an ingredient without checking EU/UK/US restrictions—an ingredient approved in one market may be banned in another. (3) Making changes so significant that the formula is no longer recognizable as the original, which blurs the line between modification and new custom development, and may breach your license if the supplier does not consent. (4) Assuming that modifying a non-exclusive formula makes it exclusive to you—it does not. If the original supplier modifies their base formula and sells it to another brand, you and the other brand now have different formulas, but neither is exclusive unless you paid for exclusivity.

Before you modify, ask your chemist or the original supplier: Is this change likely to affect stability? Will it require new stability testing? Will it require a new safety assessment in my target markets? What is the cost and timeline? In some cases, the modification is so minor (e.g., adjusting fragrance concentration by 0.2%) that new testing is not needed; in others, it triggers a full re-certification cycle.

If you are planning to modify a formula, budget for it from the start. A common founder mistake is buying a cheap, non-exclusive formula with the assumption that modification is free or quick. It is not. If modification is part of your brand strategy, factor in the chemist's fee (£500 to £2,000), stability testing (£800 to £2,000), and compliance review (£600 to £1,500)—total £1,900 to £5,500 and 8 to 12 weeks—when you decide between a stock formula, a licensed formula, and a custom formula. Sometimes, commissioning a custom formula from the start is more cost-effective and faster than buying a formula and heavily modifying it.

On AJ Cosmo Labs, if you buy a ready-made formula and want to modify it, you can hire a chemist directly from the platform to make the changes, run testing, and prepare updated compliance documentation. Many chemists specialize in formula troubleshooting and improvement and can advise whether a modification is feasible and what it will cost and take. Post your modification brief (current formula, desired changes, target markets, timeline, budget) and you will hear from approved chemists who can help.

Ingredients in this answer: Bakuchiol · Retinol

Read the full guide on Buy a Ready-Made Skincare Formula Instead of Developing One →

More about Buy a Ready-Made Skincare Formula Instead of Developing One

Tell us about your product

Tell us what you want to create and we'll set you up on AJ Cosmo Labs with your idea loaded — your first AI formulation is free.

Free to start · no credit card · continue in your browser or the iPhone app.

Have a product idea?

Connect with vetted cosmetic chemists and custom labs on AJ Cosmo Labs.

Get on the App Store Open the web app