Home›Ingredient Library›Comparisons›Texture & emulsions

Texture & emulsions

Xanthan Gum vs Carbomer: what's the difference?

By Blake Mereby · Last updated November 9, 2026

Xanthan gum is a natural thickener made by fermentation. It works across a wide pH range and tolerates salts and actives well, but used heavily it can feel slimy and makes gels slightly cloudy. Carbomer is a synthetic polymer that makes crystal-clear gels with a clean, short texture — but it must be neutralized to thicken, and it loses viscosity with salts, acids and many actives.

How they differ

Xanthan GumCarbomer
OriginNatural (fermentation)Synthetic acrylic polymer
Needs neutralizingNoYes
ClaritySlightly hazyCrystal clear
Salt / acid toleranceGoodPoor — thins out
TextureCan be slimy at high levelsClean, short, 'bouncy' gel

When to choose each

Choose Xanthan Gum if…

  • Your formula contains salts, acids or electrolytes (e.g. vitamin C, AHAs)
  • You want a natural or COSMOS-friendly thickener
  • You just need to stabilize an emulsion or suspension

Choose Carbomer if…

  • You want a crystal-clear gel
  • You want a clean, non-sticky texture
  • Your pH sits in the neutral range

Can you use them together?

Yes — a small amount of xanthan can add salt tolerance and stability to a carbomer gel. Test viscosity after adding all actives.

Side by side: library data

Xanthan GumCarbomer
FunctionThickenerThickener
INCI nameXanthan GumCarbomer
CAS number——
Typical use level0.1–2%0.1–2%
Working pH3–125–9
Solubilitywaterwater

From each ingredient's library page — values vary by supplier and grade, so always check the technical data sheet.

Common questions

Why did my carbomer gel go thin?

Common causes are salts or electrolytes, low pH from acids or actives, or not enough neutralizer. Carbomer only thickens in its neutralized form and is sensitive to ions.

More comparisons

Tell us about your formula

A vetted cosmetic chemist on AJ Cosmo Labs can recommend the right one for your product, price point and markets. Starting is free.

Free to start · no credit card · continue in your browser or the iPhone app.