Azelaic acid toners occupy a nuanced regulatory position in the United States, and getting this wrong can result in FDA warning letters, retailer delisting, and costly label redesigns after launch.
The short answer: at concentrations at or below 10% and with cosmetic-only claims, an azelaic acid toner is regulated as a cosmetic under the FD&C Act and the Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act of 2022 (MoCRA). At higher concentrations, or with drug claims, it crosses into regulated OTC drug or prescription territory.
Claims are the defining variable. The FDA's determination of whether a product is a cosmetic or a drug turns on the intended use communicated by your claims — on the label, on your website, in social media posts, and even in influencer content you facilitate. Cosmetic claims describe how a product affects appearance: "visibly minimizes the look of dark spots," "helps skin appear more even-toned," "tones and refreshes skin." Drug claims describe how a product affects the structure or function of the body or treats a condition: "treats acne," "reduces rosacea," "clinically proven to eliminate hyperpigmentation."
Concentration matters but is secondary to claims. Azelaic acid is available in 15% and 20% prescription formulations (Finacea, Azelex) in the US for the treatment of rosacea and acne. A cosmetic product using azelaic acid at 15% with drug claims would be considered an unapproved new drug. A product using 10% with purely cosmetic claims is positioned as a cosmetic — though the FDA could still challenge it if the claims imply drug intent.
For EU markets, azelaic acid is listed as a permitted cosmetic ingredient in the EU Cosmetics Regulation (Annex III has concentration restrictions for certain uses). Confirm with a EU regulatory consultant whether your specific concentration and formulation require any restriction-list compliance.
MoCRA registration: Under MoCRA (effective 2023–2024 phased rollout), cosmetic manufacturers and facilities must register with the FDA and list products. This applies to both US-based manufacturers and foreign manufacturers whose products are imported into the US. Confirm your contract manufacturer is already registered or is in the process.
The practical advice: draft your claims list before briefing a manufacturer, run them by a US cosmetic regulatory consultant, and make sure your manufacturer's safety assessment covers the claims you intend to make. Do not rely on the manufacturer to set your claims strategy — that is a brand and regulatory decision that sits with you.
AJ Cosmo Labs includes manufacturers experienced in active-ingredient formulation who can refer you to regulatory consultants in their network, helping you build a compliant azelaic acid toner from formula to label before your first production run.
Ingredients in this answer: Azelaic Acid
Read the full guide on Private Label Azelaic Acid Toner Manufacturer Low MOQ →