After you hire a formulator and receive a completed formula, your next steps are to verify safety and compliance, which are two separate responsibilities. The formulator delivers the formula (ingredient list, percentages, mixing procedure, and regulatory summary), but they do not automatically ensure the formula is safe for skin or compliant with every region where you plan to sell. You must take active steps to confirm both.
Safety assessment starts with the ingredients themselves. A competent formulator will deliver a formula with no obviously banned or toxic ingredients, but you should verify this by cross-checking the ingredient list against regional restrictions. In the US, the FDA maintains a list of banned or restricted cosmetic ingredients; the EU Cosmetics Regulation lists prohibited substances (Annex II) and restricted substances (Annex III). Some ingredients are allowed in the EU but banned in the US, or vice versa. Ask your formulator for a regulatory summary that explicitly states: "This formula complies with FDA regulations for cosmetics," or "This formula complies with the EU Cosmetics Regulation." If they did not already provide one, ask them to produce it. A regulatory summary is a short document (1–5 pages) that lists the formula, the function of each ingredient, and confirms that no banned or overly-restricted ingredients are present.
Stability testing is the second safety pillar. A formula may be safe on day one but degrade over time, producing compounds that irritate skin or become unstable (separation, mold growth, color change). Your formulator may have promised a stable formula based on their experience, but you should confirm this with testing before launching. There are two approaches: (1) Accelerated stability testing: Store the formula at 40 °C (104 °F) and 75% relative humidity for 8–12 weeks, then test for viscosity, color, odor, microbial growth, and active-ingredient degradation. This simulates approximately 1 year of real storage at room temperature and costs $500–$2,000 depending on the lab. (2) Real-time testing: Store the formula at room temperature, in a cool/dark place, and optionally in the fridge, and test it every month for 6–12 months. This is more realistic but slower and more expensive if you want monthly data points. Many indie founders do a quick accelerated test (8 weeks) to screen for major instability, and then monitor real-time performance after launch.
Safety assessment also requires a third-party review if you are risk-averse. Some indie founders send the completed formula to a cosmetic safety or regulatory consultant (not the formulator who developed it) and ask for an independent review. The consultant checks for ingredient interactions, concentrations that are safe and effective, and compliance with regulations. This adds $1,000–$5,000 and 2–4 weeks to the timeline, but it provides a second opinion and a liability shield if something goes wrong. Many larger brands do this as standard practice; small indie founders often skip it and accept the risk.
Microbial testing is critical if your formula contains water (as most emulsions, gels, and serums do). Water supports bacterial and fungal growth. Even with a preservative system, you should confirm that the formula resists microbial contamination. A standard test is the Preservative Efficacy Test (PET) or Microbial Limits Test, which measures whether the formula can resist bacterial and fungal growth over time. This typically costs $500–$1,500 and takes 4 weeks. Most contract manufacturers require PET results before they will produce your formula at scale, so budget for this test early. Your formulator should have already designed the preservative system to pass PET, but only a lab can confirm.
Regulatory compliance varies by region. In the US, you do not need pre-approval from the FDA to sell a cosmetic; you register your product with the FDA and launch. However, you must ensure that no ingredient is restricted or banned, and that you do not make drug claims (e.g., "cures acne"; "anti-wrinkle" is borderline and often flagged). In the EU, you must register every cosmetic product in the CPNP (Cosmetic Products Notification Portal) before it hits the market; registration requires the INCI declaration, the formula, safety data, and microbiological and stability data. In Canada, cosmetics are regulated by Health Canada; in Australia and New Zealand, by the TGA. If you are launching in multiple regions, your formulator should have explicitly confirmed compliance with each. If not, hire a regulatory consultant to review the formula for each region and flag any gaps.
Do not assume the formulator has done a full safety assessment. Most freelance formulators develop the formula and provide basic compliance guidance, but they do not perform stability testing, microbial testing, or formal safety assessments. These are typically outsourced to specialized labs. Ask your formulator: "What testing do you recommend before I launch?" A good answer is: "Accelerated stability testing at 40 °C / 75% RH for 8 weeks, a microbial limits test or PET, and a full regulatory review for your target markets." If they say "No testing is needed," they are underestimating the risk — test.
Common mistakes after hiring: (1) Launching without stability or microbial testing. You save money upfront but risk customer complaints, returns, and potential health issues. A single contamination incident or a formula that separates on the shelf can cost you tens of thousands in recall and reputational damage. (2) Not confirming regional compliance. If you are selling in the EU and your formulator was trained only in US cosmetics, they may have missed EU restrictions. Always get explicit compliance confirmation for each region. (3) Assuming the formulator's experience covers your specific product. If you ask for a sunscreen and they usually formulate body lotions, they may not have accounted for UV filter photostability or water-resistance requirements, which have unique testing standards. (4) Not getting testing in writing. If your formulator says "I am confident this will be stable," get that in writing and clarify exactly what they have done to test or verify stability claims. (5) Treating the formula as final before testing. After accelerated testing or the first batch of customer feedback, you may discover that the formula needs tweaking (it crystallizes over time, it separates, it feels different in a real package). Budget for a revision round and confirm with your formulator that they will revise if testing reveals issues.
If you are hiring a formulator via AJ Cosmo Labs, the formulator is vetted and has passed a credential review, which reduces the risk of hiring someone with no chemistry background. However, vetting does not include testing or compliance review — those are still your responsibility post-hire. Ask the formulator directly what testing they recommend and whether they will support you if the formula needs revision based on testing results. Some formulators include revision rounds; others charge extra. Clarify this in your contract before hiring.
Read the full guide on Best Platforms to Hire a Freelance Cosmetic Formulator →